Who Declares the Winner of Party Primaries? The Party, Not the Monitor

7
Spread the love

Every party primary produces two kinds of paper. One is the party’s own record of what happened: the collation, the results and the declaration of the winner. The other is the monitor’s record of what it observed. The Kogi West senatorial dispute, now on appeal, puts an old question sharply. If a court must choose between the two, which decides who won? With respect, the answer in law is the first.

WHAT THE CONSTITUTION GIVES INEC

Part I, Item F, paragraph 15(c) of the Third Schedule gives INEC the power to monitor the organisation and operation of political parties. Section 84(1) of the Electoral Act 2026, on which the trial court relied, places a duty on INEC to monitor primaries. The word in both is monitor. Neither provision makes INEC the conductor of the primary, the collator of its votes or the declarer of its winner. The learned trial judge himself agreed that INEC does not conduct primaries for political parties.

WHAT THE PARTY DOES

The party conducts the primary through its National Working Committee and its election committee. It accredits voters, counts, collates and declares. The APC says in its notice of appeal that conducting its primary is its sole responsibility. The returning officer reads out the results in public and declares the winner, and that declaration is the party’s own act, made in the party’s own name. In Kogi West, the returning officer, Hon. Isah Haruna, read out the figures on 18 May 2026 and declared Senator Karimi the winner, and the declaration is on video.

WHEN THE MONITOR’S PAPER IS PUT ABOVE THE PARTY’S DECLARATION

The appellants say the trial court did exactly that. It treated INEC’s monitoring report, with the ward results attached to it, as the proof of who won, and it set aside the party’s own results. A monitoring report is evidence of what a monitor saw. It cannot replace the declaration it was written to observe.

The difficulty is sharper because the author of the report says it is not its report. INEC states on oath that the documents on which the plaintiff relied were not legitimately sourced and do not reflect its official position. The judgment itself found that the report contained a presidential primary result sheet, and called it a mistake. A monitor that disowns its own paper cannot be made the maker of the winner.

The plaintiff’s documents, on which the judgment relied, give a different account of the result, and the judgment itself records that the parties presented two different sets of results from the same primary. Two accounts of one declaration cannot both stand. Only the returning officer who made the declaration can say what he read out and what he signed, and he can do so only if he is heard. That is why section 116 of the Evidence Act points to oral evidence where affidavits conflict.

The judgment also noted that INEC did not issue certified copies of the results to Senator Karimi’s side despite his application of 15 June 2026. That is an administrative omission. It cannot outweigh the fact that INEC’s own list and counter-affidavit name Senator Karimi as the winner.

THE PRIMARY THAT WAS MONITORED

The judgment held that the primary which produced Senator Karimi was invalid because INEC did not monitor it. INEC’s monitoring is not optional, and the appellants do not say otherwise. Their point is that it happened, and the judgment itself says so. Among the facts on which it records all parties as agreed, and which it says require no further proof, are that the APC conducted its primary on 18 May 2026 and that INEC monitored it under sections 83 and 84 of the Electoral Act 2026. The appellants add four grounds.

First, INEC confirmed in its own counter-affidavit that it monitored the primary. Second, INEC’s list of winning aspirants, which the appellants say was signed by its Resident Electoral Commissioner and its head of Election and Political Party Monitoring and certified on 30 June 2026, names Senator Karimi as the winner. Third, the plaintiff swore in his further affidavit that only one primary was held, yet the judgment found a second, unmonitored one. Fourth, no address summarised in the judgment is recorded as arguing that a primary is void for want of monitoring, and the court relied on authorities that appear only in its own reasoning.

The law also protects a party that does its part. The Court of Appeal has held, in Odey v. APC, that where a party gives INEC adequate notice of a primary, the party has complied and the duty to monitor falls on INEC. A party should not lose its winner because the monitor says its records lie elsewhere.

THE COURT AND THE PARTY’S CHOICE

Courts have long declined to choose a party’s candidate. The appellant cites a line of decisions to that effect, including Onuoha v. Okafor, Amaechi v. INEC and PDP v. Lawal. The judgment nonetheless declared the plaintiff the winner, set aside the submission of Senator Karimi’s name and ordered the APC to submit the plaintiff’s. The appellants say this imposes a candidate on a party that has already declared another. INEC adds that the decision relied on for this approach, Ukachukwu v. PDP, rested on provisions of earlier Electoral Acts that it says have no counterpart in the 2026 Act.

WHAT IS AT STAKE

If a monitor’s paper can outrank a party’s declaration, every disputed primary becomes a race to obtain the right document from INEC. The party’s own democratic act becomes optional. And INEC, which says it conducts nothing and disowns the report, becomes the arbiter of every primary against its will.

None of this requires the Court of Appeal to prefer one candidate to another. It requires the court to restore an order the Constitution already sets. The party decides, and the monitor observes. A declaration made in the party’s name by its returning officer is the party’s declaration, and no later paper of the monitor can unmake it without a hearing, evidence and a reason. The appellants ask the Court of Appeal to set aside the judgment.

– Sam A.I Esq.
Kogi Equity Alliance (KEA)
info@kogiequityalliance.org.ng


Spread the love