A Rejoinder to Ali Yakubu’s Facebook Publication
By Musa Tanimu Nasidi
The attention of the reading public has been drawn to a recent publication on the Facebook page of Ali Yakubu, titled “Aro Is The Candidate,” in which the writer sought to present Hon. Samuel Bamidele Aro as the authentic All Progressives Congress (APC) senatorial candidate for Kogi West, relying principally on the judgment of the Federal High Court against Senator Sunday Steve Karimi.

While everyone is entitled to express an opinion on political developments, such opinions should be anchored on verifiable facts, fairness and intellectual honesty. The public should not be subjected to selective interpretation of legal developments or statements designed to create a misleading impression about the actual state of affairs.
The emergence of Senator Sunday Steve Karimi as the APC candidate for Kogi West did not happen by accident. It followed the party’s primary election, in which he emerged victorious. His emergence was subsequently recognised in the electoral process, and the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) has released a list bearing his name as the APC candidate for the senatorial district.
The pertinent question, therefore, is: Where is the certified or officially authenticated copy of the INEC candidate list showing Hon. Samuel Bamidele Aro as the APC candidate for Kogi West?
If those insisting that Aro is the candidate are convinced of their position, they should produce the relevant official document from INEC rather than relying on social media declarations, political arguments and interpretations of a court judgment.
An appeal against a court judgment is a legitimate constitutional right, just as the enforcement of a judgment is subject to the applicable legal procedures. However, the existence of an appeal and its legal consequences must be examined within the context of the actual orders made by the court and any subsequent proceedings. Neither side should misrepresent the legal position to suit its political interests.
The question of political sincerity
Beyond the legal arguments, there is another issue that deserves public attention: the sincerity of those who have suddenly become the loudest advocates of Aro’s candidacy.
Those challenging Karimi’s emergence should answer a simple but important question: Can they, with all sincerity and before Almighty God, swear that they personally voted for Hon. Samuel Bamidele Aro during the APC primary election?
Can their political leaders make the same declaration?
If they are so convinced about their support for Aro, they should demonstrate it through verifiable evidence. Let them produce photographs, videos or other credible visual evidence showing their leaders at their respective polling units participating in the primary election and casting their votes for Aro.
This is not an attempt to suggest that photographs alone determine the validity of an election. Rather, it is a challenge to those whose present political positions appear to contradict their alleged commitment during the process that produced the party’s candidate.
Politics should not be reduced to opportunism, selective loyalty and the manipulation of public sentiment. Political reputation is built on consistency, honesty, courage and principles, not on the ability to change positions whenever circumstances become favourable.
Reputation, honesty and political principles
The contest for the APC ticket in Kogi West should not be reduced to a personality dispute between two individuals. It should also be an opportunity to examine the values that should guide political participation.
A politician’s reputation is not established by the number of statements published on social media but by consistency between words, actions and commitments.
Those who supported a particular process when they expected a favourable outcome should be prepared to defend the same process when the outcome does not favour them. Equally, those who believe that an injustice has occurred should pursue redress through lawful means without resorting to misleading public narratives.
It is important to distinguish between legitimate political disagreement and deliberate attempts to create confusion among voters.
The publication by Ali Yakubu, particularly its categorical declaration that Aro is the candidate, raises questions that deserve answers. If INEC has officially recognised Karimi in its published list, what is the basis for continuing to present Aro as the candidate without producing an equally authoritative document reflecting that position?
The right of reply and the responsibility to the public
Every individual or political camp has a right to reply to statements considered misleading, self-serving or deceptive. That right must be exercised with facts, evidence and responsibility.
It is therefore necessary to remind the author and those circulating the publication that political communication should not become an instrument for confusing the electorate.
The public deserves to know the difference between a court judgment, an appeal, an electoral party primary and an official list of candidates released by INEC. These are distinct issues that must be considered on their individual legal and electoral merits.
For the avoidance of doubt, Senator Sunday Steve Karimi remains the APC candidate reflected in the INEC list presently being relied upon in this rejoinder. His appeal against the Federal High Court judgment is part of the ongoing legal process, and the final legal position must be determined by the competent appellate court and the applicable electoral law.
Those insisting that Aro is the candidate should provide the certified or officially authenticated INEC document containing his name as the APC flagbearer for Kogi West. Let the evidence speak rather than social media propaganda.
Kogi West deserves responsible political discourse, not a contest in misinformation. The integrity of the electoral process must be protected, and political actors must learn that honesty and consistency remain essential ingredients of democratic leadership.
In politics, reputation is earned through principles, not propaganda; and facts, not sentiments, should determine public opinion.
– Musa Tanimu Nasidi writes from Lokoja.



